❝

Have you seen? We’re doing a NEW KIND OF EPISODE now—and in video! Go watch last week’s first ever on Kollo Media’s Youtube. It’s about finding your innate worth and unique, animal beauty with Bimbo Stoicism.

When I was 16 I was scouted by a modeling agency. 

A man approached me at my after school job at The Gap at Westfarms Mall and told me he thought that I had what it took. After a brief conversation, he slid a card across the metal countertop behind which I stood and said “See you Saturday.” On the card was the name and address of the agency and little blanks where he’d scribbled in a date and time. I slipped it in my front jeans pocket and felt it there for the rest of the day, charged with implications about who I had been and who I might become.

My dad drove me to the casting call out on the Berlin Turnpike—a long, bleak, straight stretch of road ensconced by strip malls that are virtually indistinguishable from one another in their dingy beigeness. I’d taken special care with my hair, slicked on a little mascara, and was wearing my best jeans and a new Gap tee shirt—black, ribbed, with a weird little collar. I remember almost nothing about what happened inside, but I know it was raining when I came back out. 

“How’d it go, Spark?” my dad asked. He’d stayed in the car, listening to an audiobook and smoking one of his gross little Swisher Sweets cigars. 

“They said I’d make a great plus-size model, unless I thought I could lose 30 pounds,” I said, carefully neutral. My dad ashed his cigar over the side of the window and inspected me, incredulous, eyes sweeping over my skinny legs and loud collarbones. 

“What, do they need skeletons for a Halloween shoot?” he asked. I was too wretched to laugh. We didn’t talk about it for the rest of the drive home and before going back in the house, I threw out the card in the big garage trash.

See, at 16, I was at the tail end of a major transformation. Up until recently I had always been fat. I don’t mean a little blurred around the edges in the way rapidly growing kids can be, but clinically, empirically, numerically chonky. I reached my zenith in sophomore year of high school at 270 pounds (122 kg), but my body had been pressing well outside the lines of “normal” since little girlhood. My bigness had defined every waking moment of my lived and imagined life—every choice I made, every summoning of mettle it took to go outside or go to school or ask a question or imagine a future in which I might be romantically desired like the other straight-sized swanlings in my grade.

Teenage Caitlin, bless her imperative ass, woke up one day and decided that she was done living this way. 

Over the summer I started losing weight, but make no mistake: this was not a glow-up montage. It was months of near-starvation and dinners consisting of only a packet of Birdseye frozen vegetable mix. It was skipping parties so I wouldn’t be tempted to eat. It was low, constant, mind-eating dread and an obsession with women’s magazines. 

And all the while, the world applauded. 

People who had never looked twice at me went out of their way to say hi. Teachers smiled at me more. Kids who had only ever asked to copy my homework suddenly wanted to be friends. Boys looked at me—no name calling after. And the change extended outside of school, too. Strangers were friendlier, waitstaff gave me free things, and people complimented me out of nowhere on my looks. It was like I’d woken up in a completely different life.

And then this: a stranger saw me and thought that I–former fat kid! Wearer of Lane Bryant and my aunt’s XXL hand-me-downs!—could be a model. My teenage brain dared to believe that, finally, I could rest—I’d truly arrived as a thin person. When that assertion was revised to be a “plus-size model,” I was crushed. No matter how hard I worked, I thought, the world would always know me for what I was: bad. Less than. Fat. 

Yes, I noticed the word I reached for first, too: not ugly, but bad.

How we make that internal leap from “not a runway model” to “bad” is what Perfect Me: Beauty as an Ethical Ideal is about. Its author, Warwick philosopher Heather Widdows, is this week's Simplify guest, and her argument is that beauty is not at all a matter of taste. It's a moral framework, something around which we build our days, measure ourselves, and feel we've failed at, ethically, when we fall short. Thinness leads her four criteria for the global beauty ideal—thinness, firmness, smoothness, and youth—because there's pretty much nothing society values more.

I found the book equal parts exhilarating and horrifying, as a former fat person with a multi-step skincare routine and internal biases I'm aware of but can't entirely excise. In the introduction, Widdows writes:

❝

"Beauty matters to individuals—to real women and increasingly men—as they navigate their lives. It matters because it makes lives go better or worse."

Heather Widdows, Perfect Me: Beauty as an Ethical Ideal

Seeing this spelled out by a serious scholar washed over me as relief. It's what I learned at sixteen, and what most of us know but rarely say: being attractive is a shortcut to many kinds of benefits. Sure, it’s not a guarantee, but it definitely helps. In our conversation, Heather runs through the evidence: attractive people get more interviews, more pay, and even more of their teachers' attention.

Thinness has gotten the biggest serving of pie in this newsletter so far, but firmness, smoothness, and youth each have their own peculiar logic. Heather and I get into all of them in the episode. We also talk about why teaching kids that Instagram faces are fake might be backfiring, what a medieval nun would make of our skincare routines, and whether the 16-year-old who believes being perfect would fix her whole life is actually wrong.

Now when I think about that modeling scout, it’s mostly something along the lines of: Damn. I could've been Ashley Graham if I hadn't tossed that card! Or at the very least I could’ve made some money. 

But Heather would complicate even that fantasy. In our conversation, she's critical of body positivity for exactly this reason: challenging one feature of the beauty ideal doesn't challenge the ideal—it reinforces it. Her examples are the well-meaning campaigns that flood social media: curvy women in flawless makeup striking pin-up poses, lovely twenty-year-olds proudly showing a little underarm hair. You're allowed to miss on one criterion as long as you nail the rest. Helen Mirren gets to be old, Heather says, because she's got everything else.

I hope you listen to this episode and get some illumination from it, maybe some relief. But also? I kind of hope you get mad. I hope it pisses you off that, too often, whether or not we’re attractive matters more than whether or not we’re good daughters, lovers, husbands, friends, community members, and parents. In the last decade or so I’ve been working on putting that second way of thinking about worth center stage and I’ve had some success. Yet and still, I just daubed on my retinoid for the night and I will go to the gym in the morning to stave off the age-related muscle loss that women in their forties are now coached to meet with resignation, heavy weights, and cute gym attire.

I doubt we’ll break meaningfully free of the beauty ideal in the rest of my natural years on earth, so let’s at least practice seeing it for what it is.

‘Til soon,
Caitlin

More soon,
Caitlin

P.S. Please share with a friend you think will enjoy this episode. It’s the best way you can help Simplify stick around! Also, let me know what you thought by replying here or writing to me and Ben at [email protected]. 

You can also follow the show on instagram at @simplifypod.

Free email without sacrificing your privacy

Gmail tracks you. Proton doesn’t. Get private email that puts your data — and your privacy — first.

Unify Your Teams and Tech Stack With HubSpot

Connect your customer data, teams, and tools without the hassle of complex integrations or lengthy setups. One easy platform gives marketing, sales, and service teams a unified customer view and the tools to turn it into growth.

Why HubSpot and what's new

  • Generate leads and automate marketing with Marketing Hub

  • Build your pipeline and close more deals with Sales Hub

  • Scale customer support and drive retention with Service Hub

  • Keep customer data clean, connected, and actionable with one, unified platform

Join 306,000+ in over 135 countries using HubSpot to grow their businesses.

See what a more connected approach to growth can do for you and your team. Get setup quickly and start checking off your hardest tasks.